A newspaper war. What side are you on?

Scott Wilson
Posted 4/24/19

The good people of Port Townsend and Jefferson County are witnessing the first salvos of what used to be called a newspaper war. That’s still at the heart of it, although it now includes news …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

E-mail
Password
Log in

A newspaper war. What side are you on?

Posted

The good people of Port Townsend and Jefferson County are witnessing the first salvos of what used to be called a newspaper war. That’s still at the heart of it, although it now includes news websites.

The Peninsula Daily News has added both news and advertising staff devoted exclusively to Jefferson County, adding muscle to an edition specifically zoned for this county. Jefferson County residents receive a version of the PDN full of Jefferson County stories; Clallam County residents receive a different version. The PDN zoned edition has been around for 25 years but tripling their Jefferson County news staff (to three) means they have almost as many reporters covering Jefferson County as does the Leader.

The PDN combines this with new advertising staff and the first of what will be a series of price breaks on subscriptions to build local readership. At one time the Leader had a four-to-one advantage in local readers; right now it’s three-to one. That’s a big margin and has easily made the Leader the best choice for advertisers or government agencies to reach local residents. I’ve always told advertisers that the PDN is a good choice if most of your customers come from Clallam County. Fewer than 20 percent of PDN readers (when I was last tracking the numbers) live in Jefferson County.

 

Be very, very careful

The Leader has gone through many changes in the last two and a half years since it moved into the hands of the Mullen family, led here by Lloyd Mullen, the publisher of what remains an independent local weekly newspaper. Some of those changes have been unsettling to longtime Leader readers and it’s not my job to defend them. There have also been improvements and upgrades. Both the financial health and, today, the newsroom of this locally based business are strong.

The newspaper war will bring benefits to both readers and advertisers. There will be more stories and more ad options. Each newspaper competitor will seek to earn your interest and your financial commitment.

But I urge you to take a long, sober view of the current dynamic, and to be very, very careful in the weeks and months ahead. There is much at stake and at risk from the decisions of readers and advertisers.

The Peninsula Daily News, once the independent homegrown newspaper of Port Angeles, has been owned by one chain or another since the 1990s and has, since late 2011, been owned by the largest chain in the Pacific Northwest. In Washington State it’s called Sound Publishing. Its parent company is Black Press, a behemoth of many small and a few large newspapers, based in British Columbia and Alberta.

Black Press owns more than 170 newspapers overall, and 49 in Washington State, as part of Sound.

David Black, a Victoria resident, has built this empire since 1975. In the last few years Black himself has turned his attention to a $22 billion oil refinery and transport project targeted at Kitimat, far north on the B.C. coast. The refinery would send 90 tankers a year to carry Canadian petroleum to Asia and is still in the permitting process. Black is a major investor and the biggest pubic booster of this project.

As the builder of a newspaper chain, Black succeeded by clustering newspapers together around a single printing and distribution facility, and consolidating staff to keep expenses low while revenues stay high.

 

War veterans

Black Press and Sound have not shied away from newspaper wars with independent local papers in order to shrink their competitor or put it out of business. They have very deep pockets and are smart at the business. They’ve been through this a dozen times, maybe more.

Black’s model has been successful in Washington State, where the Sound subsidiary has purchased most Washington newspapers that have come up for sale in the past three decades.

The list of newspapers that were once independent but are now inside the Sound portfolio is very long, and includes just about every newspaper within a two-hour drive of Jefferson County. Among them: The PDN, the Sequim Gazette, the Forks Forum, all of the weeklies in Kitsap County from towns like Poulsbo, Silverdale, Kingston, Port Orchard and Bainbridge Island; all of the weeklies on Whidbey Island, where they bought what was the sole independent competing newspaper – the Coupeville Examiner – just to shut it down.

They bought all the weeklies in the San Juans, driving one independent paper out of business. They own the weekly on Vashon Island, most of the weeklies in Pierce and King counties; the daily in Everett, the daily in Aberdeen, and they have a daily in Hawaii and in Juneau. Do a Google search on Sound or Black Press and you can see the whole list.

Terry Ward, listed as the PDN publisher and who, according to the PDN, is launching a “listening” campaign in Jefferson County, is actually a corporate vice president in charge of the Sound division that controls the PDN, the Sequim Gazette, the Forks Forum, the Aberdeen Daily World, all of the Kitsap weeklies and also Sound’s new newspaper acquisitions in Alaska – Juneau, Kenai and Homer. I’ve met him. He’s very capable. And very busy.

One of the few weeklies that is an exception to Sound’s control within 100 miles of Jefferson County is in Shelton – owned by Lloyd Mullen’s dad, Tom Mullen.

Speaking of the Mullens, it’s important to acknowledge the Leader’s ownership structure, to the best of my knowledge. Louis Mullen, Lloyd’s older brother who is based in Wyoming, owns three or four other community weeklies, mostly in Wyoming, and lives there. The Leader is the only newspaper of an independent company owned by Louis, Lloyd and a Wyoming attorney named Chris Wages. Tom Mullen is not part of this company but is an advisor. Lloyd lives in Port Townsend and is the publisher of a single newspaper: The Leader.

 

Sustaining independent media

Sound wanted to buy the Leader. Had it done so, it would have meant that one big company owned every print media outlet on the Olympic Peninsula, adding it to their stable of 50 others. All those “titles,” as Black Press calls them, look like diversity. But it’s one big company.

Saying that, I’ll add that several Sound newspapers including the PDN do solid journalism. These are not hacks. They are professionals. I’ve known and respected many of them over the years. I even met David Black once, many years ago, when he stepped off his sailboat in Port Townsend Bay and came in to ask if I would ever sell the Leader. He was pleasant and is clearly a smart guy.

After working inside the Leader and promoting independent local journalism for almost 30 years, my wife Jennifer and I decided not to sell to Sound and Black Press. In fact we did not tell Sound we were ready to move this valuable community asset on to another owner until after the deal was closed. We wanted to keep the Leader independent, which we thought then and think today is in the best interest of readers and advertisers alike.

News competition is a good thing, but it disappears if one company owns everything, consolidates its newsroom and most of the rest of its staff and functions into a larger city, leaving only two or three people in the local storefront. That’s what happened to the once independent Sequim Gazette, bought by Sound in 2011 on the same day as the PDN.

Advertising competition is also a good thing. It means one company can’t set monopoly rates.

One of the reasons we liked the Mullen family is that they were, and are, fiercely independent. One of the reasons we liked Lloyd Mullen is that he moved into our community and he and his wife are making their home here. We felt fortunate to find a young person who had grown up in this industry and who wanted to plant roots in this county.

 

Making their move

What prompted Black Press and Sound to make their move on Jefferson County and on the Leader? I haven’t talked to Sound, but here’s some relevant background.

When we owned the Leader, we had a business relationship with Sound. We paid them to print our newspaper. We had a cross-sell arrangement where at times they would sell ads into the Leader, and we would sell ads into one or more of their newspapers. Our staff attended some of their training sessions. Sound was good at printing and at sales, and over the years we had good relationships with Sound people. We cooperated with them on some levels and competed on others.

Even then, however, it was an uneasy alliance. They were always the big guys. We were the little guys. At times they threatened us. Our strength? Our emphasis on good journalism, our community-building relationships, the loyalty and extent of our readership.

The Mullens recently ended the printing relationship with Sound. The Leader today is printed by Skagit Publishing in Mount Vernon, a rare independent company with its own printing press and good rates. Even earlier, Lloyd ended the cross-sell arrangement. Now that these business ties are severed, Sound is pouncing. Make no mistake, Sound Publishing and Black Press covet this county and the plan, if successful, is to diminish or close the Leader.

 

It’s up to you

Earlier I noted that the Leader is a strong business and, with its new editor Dean Miller and some great reporters like Lily Haight, has a stronger newsroom. It’s also important for advertisers to understand more about readership numbers. The Leader has about 6,000 households; the PDN in this county has somewhere shy of 2,000 households (last time I checked). Surveys say two thirds of PDN subscribers who live in this county are also Leader readers. That means the Leader reaches most of the PDN’s Jefferson County readers. Local households that are exclusively devoted to the PDN and not the Leader number between 300 to 400, according to a survey done four years ago.

Nonetheless, through numbers, through strong customer service, through strong journalism, it’s a fact that today’s Leader has to be judged on its own merits by the community it serves.

But I hope everyone – readers, advertisers, large community non-profits, county commissioners deciding on contracts for public notice advertising – will be slow to turn away from the Port Townsend & Jefferson County Leader. I hope they will be slow to turn toward the PDN, Sound Publishing and Black Press.

There have already been some major defections in our community. You can track them by seeing who is avidly embracing the PDN as it makes its big move.

Any one decision to sign on with Sound might make sense from an individual point of view. People have their legitimate gripes. New Leader management is learning as it goes. Sound offers certain advantages, especially on pricing. That’s part of the strategy.

Taken together, however, each individual decision is a step toward losing our independent local print media to a wealthy conglomerate with distant headquarters. If we lose it, I doubt we’ll get it back.

I should note that I don’t have a financial stake in the outcome of this newspaper war. We’ve been paid. However I have a deep civic stake in this. And you do, too.

Up until now, Sound Publishing and the PDN have been content to offer a regional daily that mixes in with the Leader’s weekly presence in Jefferson County. There is news competition, and there is ad competition. That’s been great for the readers and the county. It’s been a healthy mix.

What’s new is that Sound is now moving its full weight toward taking over this market and dominating Jefferson County’s media landscape the way it dominates Clallam, Kitsap, Island and San Juan counties already, and controls most of the weekly newspapers along the I-5 corridor. That’s the decision they have made, and we’re in the opening days of the gambit. I think they’re being greedy. The question now is how Jefferson County will respond. How you will respond.

 

Expanding the equation

I think readers and advertisers in Jefferson County should retain competitive local print news sources, and retain the local option.

Let me clearly state that this is a free enterprise equation, not a mandate. Sound Publishing and Black Press are not going to back off because I wish they would. You are not going to blindly support the Leader because I said so.

Today’s Leader has to earn your respect and trust with what they actually do, with the quality of stories they investigate and tell, and has to make sure that advertisers get good service and good results from their advertising.

But the free enterprise equation should be expanded to include whatever value you place on independent, locally based print media and journalism.

- Scott Wilson

(Scott Wilson and Jennifer James-Wilson were co-owners of the Leader with Frank and Pat Garred starting in 1989, and then sole publishers from 2002 until they retired from the business in 2016.)

Comments

11 comments on this story | Please log in to comment by clicking here
Please log in or register to add your comment
Mark Couhig

I worked for the Sequim Gazette when it was purchased by Sound Publishing. While most of my colleagues were quickly let go, I hung on for a year or two before finally resigning. I know how Sound works; they are solely driven by profits. I have no objection to that; that’s how a company should be run. My issue lies in their willingness to lie about virtually everything, even those issues that don’t benefit from a covering-up. My message to Leader readers and advertisers is this: The folks at Sound will tell you all sorts of good things about themselves and their plans. Don’t believe a word of it.

Wednesday, April 24
Willem

At least some of the worst reporters at the leader have either been 'let go' or moved on. I can't count how many random days I've found out I'll be spending the next week taking a flurry of phone calls explaining the same thing over and over to angry readers simply because a story was published by a reporter who really didn't understand what they were writing about. Not sure about now, but there was a lot of focus on selling newspapers by looking for easy targets and easy controversy, stirring up the public onto the dumbest crusades.

Would the PDN be worse? Don't know. If they have the resources to put in a concentrated effort to impress the population, I don't think it'll be very difficult. The Leader's got a lot of new staff and they're going to need to raise the bar from their predecessors.

Wednesday, April 24
Brian McLoughlin

I can think of few issues more important than an independent local press. Look at companies such as Sinclair Media and what they have done to invade local markets. Sinclair Media currently airs original programming on 193 channels throughout the country, enough to reach 39 per cent of all American homes. Sinclair is a staunch supporter of Republican causes and generally a conservative mouthpiece; they were so bold as to promise favourable reporting on the 2016 Republican campaign [HYPERLINK OR CITE SOURCES]. They go so far as to mandate the content of editorials, some pre-packaged, and to pressure anchors to report the news in a particular way. This is not to condemn their politics, only their lack of balance and objectivity.

It appears that Sound Publishing and Black Press are in the process of doing the same thing to advance their private agenda, as mentioned in this article, of putting oil tankers in the Salish Sea and further endangering our delicate ecosystem. The question is not if there will be a spill, but when. It seems unlikely that the Black Press bias in favour of big corporations over the interests of citizens will end with this issue.

Regardless of your politics, be they Republican or Democrat, conservative or progressive, you need an independent press that will give you the unvarnished facts as they apply to your neighbourhood. Those voices are becoming increasingly rare. To quote Marshall McLuhan, "A point of view can be a dangerous luxury when substituted for insight and understanding.” Please, let us keep independent media—this invaluable and increasingly scarce resource that has kept this county out of the dark for 130 years—alive.

Thursday, April 25
Brian McLoughlin

In my comment, I mistakenly posted my editing draft without inserting the citation referenced by [HYPERLINK OR CITE SOURCES] It is found here: https://www.politico.com/story/2016/12/trump-campaign-sinclair-broadcasting-jared-kushner-232764

Thursday, April 25
Ryan J Huxtable

The article describes the owner of the PDN as being a "pubic booster". That's an example of the editing that has led me to drop my subscription to the Leader.

Thursday, April 25
Jason Victor Serinus

To Ryan: That's hilarious. It's a Freudian typo worth subscribing for.

Thursday, April 25
Terri Fess

Thank you Mr. Wilson for enlightening your readers about the newspaper war. We've been subscribers to the PDN and The Leader for 20 years. I just cancelled our PDN subscription.

| Thursday, April 25
Tom Camfield

Scott used many years of on-the-ground experience and a great deal of research to make this presentation. It sure looks spot-on to me.

I've been hanging around newspapers one way or another for 75 years, including publishing my own at one time, but mostly with the local Leader. Conglomerating the free press, plus the financial hit to the print newspaper by the Internet has been eroding the public's right to know for some time. Ours is among the surviving fortunate unique areas, with our own weekly family-owned Leader and the Seattle Times, one of the few major dailies in the country that is still independent and family-owned.

Many major newspapers have folded because of the financial hit, including the Seattle Post-Intelligencer. Selling out to a big-money conglomerate with a central production facility is the salvation of many smaller papers. Conglomeration is financially inspired and thus it should be no surprise that more and more newspapers wind up in conservative hands.

When I was still in harness at the Leader (before Scott's time) the Port Angeles paper already had a conservative bias. I never subscribed to it, never read it. I remember when it first spread into Jefferson County. Its Jefferson County edition didn't amount to much. As a daily, it just tried to "scoop" a few local news stories with short news bits lacking in depth. It utilized just one part-time reporter living in the local area. I guess it's after the advertising market big time these days. I don't envision it in any way being altruistically inspired to keep the local public informed.

The Leader now, also, with its on-line edition, publishes breaking news stories of major interest on a daily basis.

I've found its periodic critics to be largely grammatical nit-pickers of an apparent extreme conservative bent

| Thursday, April 25
Justin Hale

My family has subscribed to the Leader for close to 18 years, I doubt we will renew this year. With my aging eyes I do most of my reading on the computer because I can enlarge the text. I enjoyed the Letters to the editor and Tom Camfield's blogs, Tom and I have had an ongoing back and forth for a couple of years, we seldom agree on politics, but he has his opinion and I have mine. Something happened last fall and the Online edition just fell apart especially the letters and comment sections, and to this day they are not what they used to be.

If the Leader wants to keep my business they need to fix the Letters/Comment program, I suggest using the Disqus program.

Friday, April 26
Tom Camfield

I dig you somewhat there, Justin. You certainly stick to your guns. I have found you to be both frustrating and inspiring. Over it all, let's remember that the Leader is exemplifying a Free Press by providing us this opportunity of free and unedited speech. And yes, I'll rap on Trump here. He wants to destroy press freedom for his own pleasure and convenience.

There have been a lump or two in the gravy that is the paper's new online infrastructure, but they're working on these; and overall, it is a generally a more-comprehensive feature of the paper than in the past. Meanwhile, they still have an entire paper to get out each week—and a week is not all that long a time. There's more work down in the trenches than the average reader realizes.

Incidentally, I mentioned I''ve been associated with newspapers for 75 years. Actually, it's been 78 years since I was the town's only carrier boy for the Seattle Star at age 12. When it folded, I switched over to the Seattle Times.

| Friday, April 26
Jim Brennan

We recently moved from Alaska, seasonally, to Port Townsend. We were attracted to this fine town partly because of its independent identity. No box stores, no cruise ships, no contrived theme park tourist destination. A real feeling of community.

An independent local newspaper is important to a town's identity, particularly one with the quality of the Leader. I lack the longtime local experience of other commenters, but bring the perspective of a lifelong Alaskan who has lived in and read newspapers in small towns and in a large city there. I think I know a quality paper when I read it. The most recent Leader's coverage of a tragic suicide, of both sides of the issue of the search team's policies relating to this, and the deaf community's convergence on Sunrise Coffee were just excellent.

Mr. Wilson's guest editorial reminded me of Joni's adage--You don't know what you've got til it's gone. I don't yet know whether the PDN is a good and fair newspaper, but it will not reflect local sensibilities like the Leader does. Sound Publishing's owner is not shy about using his megaphone, like Hearst, to bring influence as the largest newspaper conglomerate in Canada. He is the primary proponent for the "Kitimat Clean" alternative for a $22 Billion oil refinery in northern B.C., in lieu of shipping heavy, sinkable-in-a-spill bitumin rich Alberta sands oil out through the Salish Sea, including through Juan de Fuca. His northern alternative may or may not have merit, but does Port Townsend want to examine this and other big regional issues only through the eyes of a newspaper chain with a vested interest?

I wonder why the publisher of a daily on the Olympic Peninsula feels threatened by a small local weekly, many of whose subscribers also receive the PDN. Is it due to the desire of a monopolist to bump up advertising rates after competition is killed?

We will be new subscribers to Port Townsend's 130 year old Leader.

Sunday, April 28