E-edition Log In | Subscribe | Advertise | Submit News | Contact | About | Daily E-Newsletter
The Leader - Port Townsend, Jefferson County & Olympic Peninsula's news website | Port Townsend, WA

Jim McEntire

home : news : news September 02, 2010

8/5/2009 6:00:00 AM
Health care: Hospital CEO sees workforce shortage as looming issue
Florida Rue, head of surgery at Jefferson Healthcare Hospital, pretends to check Jefferson Healthcare CEO Vic Dirksen’s pulse. Savvy about health care, Dirksen knows what his
Florida Rue, head of surgery at Jefferson Healthcare Hospital, pretends to check Jefferson Healthcare CEO Vic Dirksen’s pulse. Savvy about health care, Dirksen knows what his "normal" rate is. He’s more concerned about having enough healthcare workers like Rue to care for the coming tsunami of elderly. Photo by Allison Arthur
"I'll say upfront: I don't know of any way to do it other than single payer, but that's my opinion. That's my method. That's not the outcome."

Vic Dirksen

CEO, Jefferson Healthcare


By Allison Arthur of The Leader


Vic Dirksen worries about health care - not only about who will pay for it, but also about whether there will be enough people to care for the coming tsunami of senior citizens.

And that includes him.

As chief executive officer of Jefferson Healthcare for the past 32 years - he became the hospital's first CEO in 1977 - Dirksen comes to the healthcare debate from a local, rural-hospital and long-term perspective.

He's seen three generations of doctors, and he's been involved in numerous state committees. He was chairman of the Washington State Hospital Association, president of the Northwest Hospital Council, and has served on insurance boards and health-planning committees.

Upfront, Dirksen says he wishes President Obama would do for health care what President Kennedy did for space exploration.

"Reach for the moon and be bold" is the advice he'd give Obama to insist on a single-payer system and give a deadline for universal healthcare coverage.

Obama has said he wants quality healthcare coverage for all, and cost controls.

Dirksen doesn't see all that occurring.

"I don't see cost and quality being addressed," Dirksen said. While the nation seems plugged into the politics of who pays and how, Dirksen says a bigger problem is looming.

"My biggest fear in health care now is the workforce shortage," he said, holding out his hands, the left a foot above the right, to illustrate a growing gap between the number of people who are seeking care and the number of people who are providing care.

A decade from now, even if people opt to retire later in life because of current economic woes, "it doesn't close the gap," Dirksen said.

His analysis is backed by the Institute for Medicine, which concluded a year ago that when the nation's 78 million baby boomers begin reaching 65 in 2011, "they will face a healthcare force that is too small and woefully unprepared to meet their specific needs."

Sooner rather than later, Dirksen says, the country needs to change how care is delivered.

"I think we're going to have to redesign how we deliver care. And it's not going to be the same as it was in the past," he said.

It's a conversation Dirksen fears will be lost in the din of "who pays?"

"I'm personally concerned about it for myself," said Dirksen, who turns 63 this month, two years away from going on Medicare.

"Am I going to have the services I need? Will the providers be there?"

"We talk about 'Who is going to pay the bill?' as opposed to 'What are we buying?'" - a question that would lead to a discussion about quality of care and workforce shortage.

As an example of what he's talking about, he points to a new stroke program at the hospital that connects patients to Swedish Medical Center via computers.

Neurologists who deal with stroke patients wanted to be able to use their skills and resources to help those who would benefit from their care. That meant they needed a quicker way to treat the ones they could help and divert the ones who didn't need their specialized services.

"We're now a filter where we connect them through telehealth, where we send them the ones they can make a difference with," Dirksen said.

More such filters are needed to ensure limited specialists and limited resources are being used wisely.

Another example of what he's talking about with "how we deliver care" has to do with thrombolytic therapy, drugs that break up or dissolve blood clots, which are the main cause of both heart attack and stroke.

Jefferson Healthcare wanted to be able to stock ambulances with the drugs to get them to patients who needed them quickly, but it discovered no insurance program would cover the $15,000 cost of putting the drugs on ambulances.

The hospital had a choice of abandoning the idea or paying for it and taking the risk of not being reimbursed.

In reality, Dirksen, who lives on Morgan Hill, says he certainly could make more money for the hospital if a patient were to go directly to Jefferson Healthcare's emergency room.

"We could take Vic here and charge for the ER and the hospital stay and the therapy," he said.

But for the sake of the patient - he often uses himself as an example - it would be better to get the thrombolytic drugs at the scene, in the ambulance, regardless of what insurance pays.

In essence, the system now isn't designed necessarily for what's best for the patient.

Ultimately, the hospital bit the bullet and bought the drugs, and since learned that Harrison can replace the drugs once a patient is transported to its facility.

"If we don't have healthcare reform, at least pay for the cost of providing service," Dirksen said.



Wilder Nissan

The pay issue

As for who pays for care, Dirksen is in favor of a single-payer system.

"I'll say upfront: I don't know of any way to do it other than single payer, but that's my opinion. That's my method. That's not the outcome," he said. He wants to educate people about the difference between who pays and what the quality of the care is.

A regional or national single-payer system under one umbrella makes sense, he says. But he's aware that there are differences of opinion.

"It doesn't matter what Vic wants. What really matters is what we as a nation want. And I'm not sure. I'm not sure we have an agreement on that. I think one thing most people can agree on is that most people don't want people to go bankrupt as a result of healthcare costs. And I think most people but not everyone believes we ought to have accessible medical care."

And people are going bankrupt because of health care.

The American Journal of Medicine reports that in 2001, 62.1 percent of all bankruptcies were related to medical issues. That was up dramatically from 1981, when only 8 percent of families filed for bankruptcies in the "aftermath of a serious medical problem."

Again, Dirksen is concerned that the national discussion is being diverted from quality issues to that of who pays.

"I'm not sure everyone agrees on accessible health care," he said, questioning what that encompasses. Does it include preventive care, for example?

Dirksen, who says he sees health care as a right, says the problem now is that "we have a system that is not taking care of our citizens adequately and we have a system that is costing businesses and individuals more than it's costing in other countries."

Interestingly, Dirksen says there are systems in the United States that are working well to address quality and access issues.

So-called "closed systems," such as those offered by Group Health that offer insurance, providers and hospital services all in one package and focus on taking care of a patient by offering easy access to services, "are ahead of us."

"If you are a Group Health member, if you stay well, they benefit," Dirksen said of that system keeping costs down while also providing care.

"If you can have the access, if the care can be coordinated, if you can recruit and retain quality people in health care, that's what I want. We've been working with this free-market system for years and haven't gotten there. I look at other countries that get better scores than us," he said. Other industrialized countries with national healthcare systems fare better on patient satisfaction scores, not just the bottom-line issue of cost.

 

Full discussion

While he wishes Obama would seek a single-payer system like Medicare, Dirksen says Obama is taking the right tack by involving everyone in the discussion.

"The Clintons went into back rooms, and they came out with a product Congress didn't understand," Dirksen said.

Still, Dirksen is concerned that the focus has been more about "coverage for all" than it has been about reform.

And he also clearly worries about that nagging workforce issue.

In any future of health care, Dirksen says people should realize it will take more providers to fill in for retiring physicians.

"When you have a physician retire today, it takes close to two physicians to replace the one who retired because physicians are wanting more reasonable lifestyles than their predecessors have," he said.

Dirksen has seen three generations of physicians pass through the hospital doors.

The first generation of doctors couldn't understand the next generation of doctors who went home for dinner instead of heading for the hospital or homes to see patients.

Today's physicians want to have lives, too, not just see patient after patient nonstop and do paperwork that seems to be growing, even with laptops coming into use.

 

Leaning into change

It's not just physicians who are changing. Jefferson Healthcare also is changing.

And almost any conversation Dirksen has these days includes comments about Lean, a program that employs the so-called Toyota management method.

"The core idea is to maximize customer value while minimizing waste. Simply, Lean means creating more value for customers with less resources," according to lean.org.

"I wish we had gone to Lean when we first learned about it. We're only in Phase 1," Dirksen said.

About 40 percent of employees have gone through the Lean system in various departments, Dirksen estimates.

The system has worked so well that it's actually saved one department, the laundry service, which the hospital was at one point thinking of outsourcing.

Because of changes made in the department, many based on suggestions by employees, the hospital is now looking at replacing equipment and not laying off anyone.

Lean also was implemented in clinics, and because of changes made using the Lean model, the clinics were able to start taking new patients. Not long ago, they were turning patients away, Dirksen said.

It all gets back to delivery of care - a subject that might not be on the national radar, but one that Dirksen says he hopes will be soon.  





Reader Comments

Posted: Friday, August 07, 2009
Article comment by: Earll Murman

Vic Dirksen's proposals are right on target. He understands what is needed to fix US healthcare. I am very impressed with what Jefferson Healthcare is doing for our community.



Article Comment Submission Form
We welcome your comment to this story, to be posted after a website editor's review.

Please stay on topic, provide credible information or insight that moves the discussion forward, be convincing and try to be brief. Your comment won't be edited, so all of it is posted or none of it is posted.

Own your words and post your full name, although single name or alias comments will be considered. An authentic email address and phone number are for our use only. NOTE: site software requires that all fields be filled out.
Submit an Article Comment
First Name:
Required
Last Name:
Required
Phone:
Required
Email:
Required
Message:
Required
Passcode:
Required
Anti-SPAM Passcode Click here to see a new mix of characters.
This is an anti-SPAM device. It is not case sensitive.
   


Advanced Search


TOP ADS
PERSONAL CARE STAFF
RETAIL CLERKS
SUBSTITUTE TEACHERS